As the trial begins, Josh and his team experience some hiccups in proving Lavinia's innocence to the judge. As soon as Josh thinks he's been able to find cause for dismissal of the case, Carol Anne argues to test the timeline herself, leading them to uncover a hidden passageway on Lavinia's property.
- Nicholas D'Agosto as Josh Segal
- Jayma Mays as Carol Anne Keane
- Steven Boyer as Dwayne Reed
- Sherri Shepherd as Anne Flatch
- Kristin Chenoweth as Lavinia Peck-Foster
- Amanda Payton as Nina Rudolph