In the aftermath of winning Lavinia's case, the town finally embraces Josh as a real Pecker. However, Josh agonizes over whether or not Lavinia may have done it and, unable to try Lavinia again for Edgar's murder, Josh takes a big swing by trying to open an old case.
- Nicholas D'Agosto as Josh Segal
- Jayma Mays as Carol Anne Keane
- Steven Boyer as Dwayne Reed
- Sherri Shepherd as Anne Flatch
- Kristin Chenoweth as Lavinia Peck-Foster
- Amanda Payton as Nina Rudolph